Head-to-head comparison
OneUp Trader vs TradeDay
Compare FirmFax scores, account rules, reputation, fees, platforms, and current offers before choosing.
OneUp Trader vs TradeDay
TradeDay leads by 16 FirmFax points.
Best account
Evaluation 63/100 account scoreBest account
Funded Live 93/100 account scoreFast answer
TradeDay is the clearer pick here: it scores 16 points higher on the FirmFax master score (81 vs 65) and starts $20 cheaper. Because they handle drawdown differently — OneUp Trader runs intraday trailing, TradeDay runs end-of-day trailing, the deciding factors come down to cost and track record.
Best for OneUp Trader
Pick OneUp Trader for Evaluation, its top-scored tracked account at 63/100.
Best for TradeDay
Pick TradeDay for Funded Live, its top-scored tracked account at 93/100 — 30 points clear of OneUp Trader's best account.
Next step
TradeDay
Missing info
A or B or C
Best account: Funded Live. 55% off, accounts from $45.
The short version
What actually separates them
4 fields on the record split OneUp Trader and TradeDay — the three that change how you trade are here. Everything else either matches or is not on the record yet.
Intraday trailing tightens against your open profit; end-of-day trailing only resets at the close; static never moves. This is the rule most likely to end an account.
A daily loss limit ends the session, not the account — but it decides how many attempts a bad open costs you.
Entry cost for the cheapest account each firm sells, before any live discount.
Not comparable yet: consistency rule, activation fee, minimum days to a first payout — at least one of the two firms has no figure on record, so we do not draw a conclusion from it. A blank here means we have not confirmed the rule, not that the firm has none.
Fig. 01 — Category winners
Who wins each category
TradeDay wins more categories (4–2), but the right pick depends on which category matters most to you.
Price
TradeDay is cheaper to enter ($45 vs $65).
Drawdown
TradeDay uses a more forgiving end-of-day trailing drawdown.
Payouts
OneUp Trader keeps a higher trader split (90% vs 50%).
Rules
TradeDay has fairer rules overall (58 vs 21 on rule fairness).
Platforms
OneUp Trader supports more platforms (12 vs 6).
Overall value
TradeDay has the higher overall FirmFax score (81 vs 65).
A “tie” means both firms publish the same answer. “No data” means one of them has no figure on record for that category, so there is nothing to compare — it is never a point against either firm.
Buyer guide
Which one should you choose?
OneUp Trader is stronger when...
- Pick OneUp Trader for Evaluation, its top-scored tracked account at 63/100.
- Entry cost: $65 starting price, $65 activation fee.
- Risk model: intraday trailing drawdown, daily loss limit Plan-specific — confirm it fits how you size trades.
- We have no consistency rule recorded for OneUp Trader — check its rules page before you plan around one big day.
- Payouts: 100% first $10k, then 90/10 above withdrawal threshold, Funded-trader withdrawal threshold rules apply by account size.
TradeDay is stronger when...
- Pick TradeDay for Funded Live, its top-scored tracked account at 93/100 — 30 points clear of OneUp Trader's best account.
- Entry cost: $45 starting price, activation fee not recorded.
- Risk model: end-of-day trailing drawdown, daily loss limit None — confirm it fits how you size trades.
- Watch the 30% consistency rule before you scale into a big day.
- Payouts: Quick Pay Sim 50/50 below $4k current profit, 80/20 above threshold; Funded Live 90/10, Requests before cutoff targeted for next-business-day processing, first withdrawal from 1 day.
Before you buy
TradeDay is $20 cheaper to start ($45 starting price), but weigh activation fees and any live discount before deciding.
Both firms sit at 0 logged status issues, so status issues are level in this matchup.
Payout cadence differs — OneUp Trader is Funded-trader withdrawal threshold rules apply by account size, TradeDay is Requests before cutoff targeted for next-business-day processing — which compounds if you withdraw often.
Freshness: OneUp Trader was last reviewed 2026-09-06; TradeDay on 2026-09-09.
Fig. 02 — Score breakdown
Where each firm is stronger
A dash means the factor is unscored for that firm — the evidence it needs (a founding year, a public review sample) is not on record, so its weight moves to the factors that do have evidence rather than counting as a zero.
Fig. 03 — Same size, side by side
Compared at a $50,000 account
| At $50,000 | OneUp Trader | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Max drawdown | $2,500✓ | $2,000 |
| Profit target | $3,000 | $3,000 |
A bigger max drawdown gives more room; a lower profit target is easier to clear. A dash means that figure is not on record at this size, so no checkmark is awarded either way. Review the exact figures for your selected account.
Fig. 04 — The tale of the tape
Head-to-head
| Metric | OneUp Trader | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| FirmFax master score | 65 | 81✓ |
| Best account score | 63 (Evaluation) | 93 (Funded Live)✓ |
| Reputation | Strong reputation | Strong reputation |
| Founded | 2017✓ | 2020 |
| Starting price | $65 | $45✓ |
| Activation fee | $65 | Not recorded |
| Markets | Futures | Futures |
| Jurisdiction | USA | USA |
| Platforms | NinjaTrader, R Trader, R Trader Pro, Trade Navigator, VolFix, eSignal, Jigsaw, ATAS, Bookmap, Quantower, Sierra Chart, Medved Trader | Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView, Quantower, Jigsaw, Rithmic |
| Drawdown | Trailing (intraday) | Trailing (end-of-day) |
| Daily loss limit | Plan-specific | None |
| Consistency rule | Not recorded | 30% |
| Profit split | 100% first $10k, then 90/10 above withdrawal threshold | Quick Pay Sim 50/50 below $4k current profit, 80/20 above threshold; Funded Live 90/10 |
| Payout frequency | Funded-trader withdrawal threshold rules apply by account size | Requests before cutoff targeted for next-business-day processing |
| Min days to payout | Not recorded | 1 |
Checkmarks flag the objectively better value (higher score/reputation, older firm, lower price/fee) and are only awarded when both firms have that figure on record — “Not recorded” never loses a row. Rules are shown side by side without a “winner” because the best choice depends on your strategy.
Current offer
Check current discount
Verified discount
55% off, accounts from $45
Official source · Last verified 2026-09-05
Search answers
OneUp Trader vs TradeDay FAQ
Is OneUp Trader or TradeDay better for futures traders?
TradeDay has the higher best-account FirmFax score right now. The better pick is the one whose end-of-day trailing drawdown, platforms, and fees match how you trade.
Which is cheaper, OneUp Trader or TradeDay?
TradeDay has the lower verified starting price — about $20 less in this dataset. Discounts can change often.
How do drawdown rules compare between OneUp Trader and TradeDay?
OneUp Trader uses intraday trailing drawdown and TradeDay uses end-of-day trailing drawdown. Intraday trailing tightens fastest, so it is the stricter style to trade under.
Do OneUp Trader and TradeDay have a consistency rule?
We have no consistency rule on record for OneUp Trader, and TradeDay enforces a 30% consistency rule. A blank is not a "no rule" — confirm it on the firm page before you count on it.
Does FirmFax rank OneUp Trader vs TradeDay using payouts?
Payout history is used as context. FirmFax scores focus on rules, track record, trader reputation, transparency, and accessibility.
More comparisons